
Having the ability to produce website content in a matter of minutes and for free – who wouldn’t want that? Small business owners rejoice in the idea, many of them ending long-lasting relationships with the copywriters who previously made their online presence outstanding.
As a freelance copywriter, I’ve had to face the harsh reality of a transforming digital landscape.
Numerous business partnerships I dedicated years to ended abruptly at the beginning of 2024.
The reduction in project volume was so significant that I had to get a credit card issued for the first time in my life. Otherwise, I feared lacking enough funds to celebrate my son’s third birthday.
Artificial intelligence has had a profound impact on copywriting and writing in general. Some troubling surveys suggest that a third of translators and 20 percent of writers lost their jobs because of AI.
It’s a reality we have to face. Statistics suggest that nearly 300 million jobs could be lost to AI. Approximately 14 percent of professionals may be forced to seek a career change, and nearly 60 percent of the jobs in advanced economies are at risk of being replaced.
Such dynamic shifts can be scary, but it’s not all doom and gloom.
Going back to copywriting, I believe many have been impacted (yours truly included). Will human copywriters become obsolete, however? The answer is a definitive no. Regardless of its learning capabilities, AI will never replace human creativity.
Whether you’re a freelance professional or a business owner interested in optimizing marketing, here’s what I have to share with you on the topic of AI replacing content written by humans.
Can AI Do Good Copywriting?
The diplomatic thing to say here is that the quality of copy that AI produces depends on the quality of the input. A detailed, specific prompt is more likely to produce well-written, cohesive texts.
What I believe in, however, is that AI cannot do good copywriting.
I asked ChatGPT to answer the question that this section’s title poses. Here’s what it produced:
AI can certainly generate copy that is clear, structured, and even engaging to a point. It’s excellent at producing large volumes of content quickly, making it useful for things like product descriptions, social media captions, or SEO-driven articles. However, “good copywriting” isn’t just about stringing words together — it’s about understanding psychology, weaving in emotion, and adapting tone to a brand’s unique voice. These are areas where AI still falls short. While it can mimic patterns of persuasive writing, it often lacks the subtlety, originality, and strategic intent that human copywriters bring to the table. In other words, AI can deliver functional copy, but truly effective copywriting — the kind that builds trust and moves people to act — still requires a human touch.
That’s a perfectly fine response… but it’s bland and generic.
The copy lacks personality, direction, and attitude.
If you’re just looking for ways to produce quick content for your website, ChatGPT is an excellent tool.
Drafting copy that engages and converts, however, is a completely different ball game.
People aren’t moved by chunks of text that are factually correct (which can also be an issue for ChatGPT, but more on that later). They want texts that share the human experience or expertise. They want to be enlightened or entertained. Good luck accomplishing either of those via ChatGPT or another AI-powered content creation tool.
Will Copywriting Be Replaced by AI?
To some extent, human writing will be replaced by AI.
Traditional SEO texts and pieces of content created for the purpose of having enough pages on a website are already non-existent as freelance copywriting project niches.
High-end copywriting, however, will always necessitate human creativity and input.
Even if AI is used to streamline and speed up some aspects of content production, a human mastermind will still need to be behind the crafting and execution of a content-based campaign.
Reasons Why Human Copywriters Will Never Become Obsolete
Let’s list some of the most important reasons why human copywriters will never become obsolete, no matter how much AI improves over the years.
- Original point of view: AI regurgitates information available in its vast database. It’s not capable of original thought or an original creative approach. Sure, you can ask it to replicate the style of Hemingway, but the outcome will lack substance and depth. It will be an empty copy that few readers will feel inspired by.
- Fact-checking: I’ve already mentioned the vast database that fuels AI content generation. A lot of the texts that ChatGPT uses to answer questions and produce copy aren’t fact-checked. As a result, AI content tools can produce copy that isn’t factually correct. This is a massive problem, especially in sensitive fields like finance, law, and medicine.
- AI has no understanding of brand tone and voice: Each company wants to present itself in a certain way. AI has no understanding of those specifics. A good prompt can lead to the generation of decent copy, but that’s what it’s going to be at best.
- AI is disastrous for reputation establishment: Do you want to be seen as an expert and authority within your business field? Good luck using AI to accomplish that goal. Readers are becoming increasingly good at recognizing AI content. The fact you rely on such a tool rather than human expertise to produce content can have a negative impact on your brand.
- Creativity with purpose: Creativity for the sake of creativity is good, but when you’re trying to sell or you have a specific marketing goal, it’s simply not enough. Only a human understands marketing purpose and can employ the right type of creativity to accomplish something specific.
- Storytelling and the human perspective: I asked ChatGPT whether AI can tell stories. Its response is expected: AI can generate stories by piecing together patterns from the vast amount of text it’s trained on. So, the answer is no. AI can’t tell stories and it doesn’t have the human perspective… because it’s not human. All these things matter when you’re trying to attract the attention of an audience already exposed to dozens of different messages.
AI Tools Are Still Incredibly Beneficial for Copywriters and Their Clients
In those early days, I was radically opposed to adopting AI.
After all, I work in a creative field. My clients pay for human input. Using ChatGPT during any stage of the process felt like cheating.
Today, I’ve become a bit more open to new realities. AI is here to stay. It has already changed the way we do copywriting work, and it will continue doing so.
I find ChatGPT incredibly beneficial during the ideation process. It’s a wonderful tool as far as brainstorming goes. I’ve also used it to understand clients better, sharpen my pitches, and eliminate repetitive or tedious processes like proofreading (obviously, to an extent).
AI tools can make copywriters better, faster, and more prolific. The adoption of such tools will ultimately benefit both professionals and their clients, as long as ChatGPT and its derivatives are used the right way.
Final Verdict
Are you wondering whether you should hire a human copywriter for an upcoming campaign?
I suggest doing so if you can afford the expense.
Original copywriting, especially when strategic and done by a professional, delivers an excellent return on investment. Building such a partnership will give your brand a strong, recognizable voice. You can still employ AI for basic writing tasks, but when it comes to consistent marketing, choosing a copywriter will be the better approach.
Do you have questions about copywriting and the role AI plays in it? Contact me and I’d be more than happy to have your questions answered.
Are you a freelancer struggling with today’s reality? My latest book can help you understand the role of AI in copywriting, helping you make the most of the tool. The ebook is available on Amazon, Apple Books, Rakuten Kobo, Barnes & Noble, and Smashwords.
FAQ
Q. What can AI do better than human copywriters?
AI is faster, so much faster than a human copywriter! It can also scale up effortlessly, addressing a client’s need for a large volume of content being produced immediately. ChatGPT and paid AI copywriting tools have also become really good at doing SEO, as long as a human provides sufficiently clear input about the scope and specifics of the project.
Q. What can a human copywriter do that AI can’t?
A human copywriter can get creative, even experimental, with content creation. Humans can also weave humor or personality into the text – something that artificial intelligence will never be capable of.
Q. Is hiring a copywriter still worth it in 2025 and beyond?
Yes, especially if you’re focused on quality and giving your brand the most distinctive voice.
Q. What are the risks of using solely AI-generated copy?
AI-generated copy sounds bland and generic. There’s also the risk of publishing texts that feature factual errors – a mistake that can easily destroy your reputation. Statistics suggest that more than 54 percent of people can already easily identify AI content. Consumers remain hesitant about such copy, and some research even suggests they’re turned off by it.
Q. Do readers notice when content is written by AI rather than by a human?
Yes, readers are becoming increasingly good at recognizing AI content. Millennials are the demographic group most skilled at recognizing AI texts. Studies also suggest that AI content can affect the attitude and perception of readers. In a poll, 52 percent of respondents reported that AI copy is likely to make them less engaged. Consumers find brands using AI impersonal and lazy.
